This blog post was written and published by Linden Alexander Pentecost, and was published (after an unrelated blog post was published on this website earlier today) on the morning of the 20th of November, 2026. This blog post is unrelated to and separate from any and all of my other publications, it was published in the UK, and no AI was used. This blog post contains a total of 1182 words. More content was added on the 21st of November 2026.
Esselen is a fascinating language of coastal California. Whilst sometimes incorrectly grouped into the "Hokan" language family, which is a questionable "language family", Esselen can only be truly classified as a language isolate, or belonging to its own family, even though there are connections with other language families in the "Hokan" classification group, and also similarities to other Indigenous American languages and to Uralic languages in Eurasia. A curious things about the languages in this area which have been specifically linked to Uralic languages by Arnaud Fournet, aka the Esselen, Salinan, Chimariko and Costanoan languages - all have rhotic r sounds, with the Chimariko language having possessed a strongly rolled r, from my understanding, and with the others have tapped r sounds with possible trilled/rolled r variations. Outside of parts of California and Mexico, e.g. the Purepecha language in Mexico - true rolled r sounds are incredibly rare in the Americas, and I wonder if the presence of rolled r sounds in these languages relates in some way to the possible connections with Uralic, where rolled r sounds are found throughout Uralic languages and are arguably one of their most distinctive common phonemes. The Purepecha language also shares I think a number of similarities with Uralic languages, but I do not go into these here.
As I have discussed very extensively elsewhere - connections between Uralic and Native American languages increase greatly when we look at the languages of the Andes, with Quechua in my opinion and from my research having the greatest lexical and other similarities to Uralic languages. However, as I have also discussed in detail, these connections are not limited to the Andes, and I have also written about how languages of Coastal California, and elsewhere, have commonalities with Uralic. The author who initially looked into this in great detail is Arnaud Fournet, in his publication: A Preliminary Survey of Some Uralic Elements in Costanoan, Esselen, Chimariko and Salinan. I have not read this publication in a while and have primarily discussed it in reference to Salinan, a language isolate of coastal California - but in this blog post on this page I look more closely, from my own research, at Esselen and Uralic similarities, although I do not give a great number of examples. Note that much of this original work was done in the book: The Discovery of California: A Cal-Ugrian Comparative Study, by Otto von Sadovszky
Let us look at the vocabulary of Esselen for example. In Esselen, kilí- (1) is "salmon", which can be compared for example to Finnish kala - "fish", Mari kol - "fish", Northern Sámi guolli - "fish", Quechua challwa - "fish" and many others. We see also in Esselen a number of other examples of this or of related roots, for example Esselen koxlkoxl - "fish" (2), and Esselen kalu-l - "fish" (2), with kalu-l being closest to Finnish kala, and with koxlkoxl perhaps being based upon the same root, but with a twofold reduplication process visible. Another interesting example is Esselen tumas (1) - "dark", compare for example Finnish tumma - "dark".
Numerals in Esselen also show clear similarities to Uralic and Quechuan. "One" in Esselen is pek (1), which is quite different from Finnish yksi, but we can find a possible cognate to pek in the Puquina language of Peru, where pesq means "one", which can be more generally compared to Finnish yksi, Kallawaya uksi, Quechua huq/shuk etc, with Quechua and Kallawaya arguably having the largest numbers of Uralic similarities out of any indigenous American languages. The numbers "two" and "three" in Esselen, are kxulax (1) and kxulep (1) respectively. I am inclined to think that the Esselen number 2 was based upon a root that originally meant "three", which is why we find similarities here to Keresan and many other words for "three", Quechua kimsa, Mapuche küla, Finnish kolme etc. Furthermore, the -p in kxulep (1) and the m in Quechua kimsa could be feasibly be from the equivalent phoneme point which gives the m in Finnish kolme. The Esselen word for "ten", tomóila (1) also possesses similarities to Finnish kymmenen - "ten", and to Quechua chunka - "ten" and to Aymara tunqa - "ten".
California is also arguably very curious for the fact it was originally drawn as an island by early cartographers. Why? Who knows. There are the large variety of Native American tribes known from California, whilst some old legends implied that there were also black Native Americans, and tall, giant, white Native Americans on some of the offshore islands. As to the truth of these things, who knows, but I fear that a focus upon the aforementioned can distract from the fact that California was Native American land, and I do pray that those tribes receive more recognition and continue to bring back those of their languages which have become moribund, and many have been brought back.
Another interesting thing I would like to bring up is the presence of the "East Bay Walls" near to San Francisco in California, which are another possible aspect of California's more mysterious ancient history, and to the legends of California being an island, and of black and white, as well as more typically looking Native Americans there. The East Bay Walls are drystone wall structures. Whilst some lichen dating on the stones puts them into the mid 1880s, this dating method is not without its faults, and the sampling was only partial. Indeed some sections of these walls, and of similar walls in that part of California, do resemble both the drystone walls of Northern England, and some of the stone rows of Cumbria. The particular groups of "East Bay Walls" within the Sierra Vista Open Space Preserve are especially akin to stone rows and similar structures, from what I have observed in photos. Meanwhile, in the Santa Lucia Mountains, there are legends of the "Dark Watchers", mysterious figures, often wearing hats, said to observe people in the area of those mountains. Many consider the Dark Watchers to be spiritual guardians of the region, and the "hat" element is curious, and connects to other figures in mythology.
References:
(1): Shaul, David L. 1995. "The Huelel (Esselen) Language." International Journal of American Linguistics 61:191-239.
(2): Shaul, David (2019). Esselen studies: language, culture, and prehistory. Munich: Lincom Europa
I hope that this blog post was an interesting read, and thank you for reading. It is written in honour of the Esselen people and of other Indigenous peoples of California.
Add comment
Comments